UNSCEARの続き、2008年ではOxfordの記述は？、代わりにチェルノの低線量被曝における子供の白血病に関し、10mSv(mGy)未満の関連性はないと頻りに主張する下りあり。ICRPが最も採用しているUNSCEARですら10mSvと主張、今回の20mSvは理論的におかしいです。勘違いだったらご容赦。

UNSCEAR2000

AnnexG p121
In the Oxford Survey of Childhood Cancers, a statistically
significant 40% increase in the childhood leukaemia rate (up
to 15 years of age) has been seen following doses of
10-20 mGy (low-LET).

AnnexG p120
when children would have received a dose
from fallout of about 1.5 mSv, compared with the adjacent
“medium” exposure period, when the dose received would
have been about 0.5 mSv (relative risk for ages 0 14 years
is 1.07; 95% CI: 1.00 1.14). These data are consistent
with a relative risk of 1.03 predicted with the BEIR V
leukaemia model

UNSCEAR2008

AnnexD p173
Because radiation doses were very low (median dose was
less than 10 mGy), the statistical power of the analyses was
diminished [U1]. The authors concluded that “this study
provides no convincing evidence of an increased risk of
childhood leukaemia as a result of exposure to Chernobyl
radiation”

Reply · Report Post